OH directory

Amish Stores in Ohio

Browse 47 Amish stores, markets, and shops in Ohio. Compare contact details, towns, store types, products, and route-planning notes before you visit.

47 Stores Found

Ohio hill country farm market exterior without readable signs — Editorial image for regional planning, not a photo of a specific listed store.

Ohio is home to the largest Amish population in the United States, with approximately 80,000 Old Order Amish living across more than a dozen counties. The first Amish settlers arrived in Wayne and Holmes counties in the early 1800s, drawn by affordable farmland and the religious freedom the young nation offered. By the mid-19th century, Holmes County had become the undisputed center of Amish life in America, a distinction it holds to this day. The rolling hills of northeastern Ohio proved ideal for small-scale farming and the self-sufficient agricultural life the Amish sought.

The Holmes County settlement, which spills into portions of Wayne, Coshocton, Tuscarawas, and Stark counties, is often called the single largest contiguous Amish settlement anywhere in the world. To the south, Tuscarawas County hosts a distinct community of Swiss Amish — descendants of immigrants from the Bernese Oberland region of Switzerland — who settled around Sugarcreek and Dover in the late 1800s. Smaller but historically significant settlements also exist in Geauga County in northeastern Ohio, dating to the 1880s.

Today, Ohio Amish country draws millions of visitors annually, yet large swaths of the region remain working farmland where horse-drawn equipment is an everyday reality, not a tourist attraction. The combination of deep historical roots, diverse sub-communities, and a thriving artisan economy makes Ohio the definitive destination for anyone seeking authentic Amish goods, food, and craftsmanship.

Communities & Character

Holmes County is the gravitational center of Ohio Amish life, with towns like Berlin, Millersburg, Walnut Creek, and Charm serving as hubs for both residents and visitors. Berlin has become a commercial focal point, hosting furniture showrooms, bulk food stores, and specialty shops. Old Order Amish use horse-drawn transportation and shun grid electricity, while more conservative Swartzentruber Amish live under stricter Ordnung rules, foregoing indoor plumbing and reflective safety triangles on their buggies.

Geauga County's Amish community, centered around Middlefield and Parkman, is known for maple syrup production, cheese making, and furniture. The Swiss Amish of Sugarcreek are recognized for their distinctive yodeling tradition, Swiss-style architecture, and a slightly more entrepreneurial approach to retail that includes the famous Sugarcreek Budget newspaper, a national clearinghouse for Amish community news.

What Ohio is Known For

Handcrafted hardwood furniture (oak, cherry, maple)
Aged and fresh cheeses including Baby Swiss
Bulk dry goods and baking supplies
Fresh-baked pies, whoopie pies, and cinnamon rolls
Quilts and hand-stitched textiles
Maple syrup and maple candy
Canned and pickled goods (chow-chow, apple butter, jams)
Handmade brooms, baskets, and wooden kitchenware

Best Time to Visit

Late spring through early fall is when Ohio Amish country operates at full capacity. Fall is arguably the single best time to visit: apple butter festivals, the Sugarcreek Ohio Swiss Festival in late September, harvest produce, and freshly pressed cider fill roadside stands. Winter sees reduced hours and some seasonal stands close December through March. Spring brings maple syrup season in Geauga County. Virtually all Amish businesses close on Sundays — plan your visit for Tuesday through Saturday.

Travel Tips

State Route 39 between Millersburg and Sugarcreek is the main commercial corridor — drive it slowly and plan stops at Walnut Creek, Berlin, and Charm.
Buggy traffic is heavy on county roads; leave extra following distance and never pass on blind hills.
Carry cash — the majority of farm stands, bulk food stores, and home bakeries are cash-only, and ATMs in rural Holmes County are scarce.
Use the Amish Country byway maps available at the Holmes County Chamber of Commerce — GPS routing frequently sends vehicles down private farm lanes.
If buying furniture, ask about the shop's builder and lead times — custom pieces can take 6–12 weeks.

Cultural & Etiquette Notes

Visitors to Ohio Amish country are guests in a working religious community, not a theme park. Photography is the most common source of friction: Old Order Amish generally object to having their faces photographed on theological grounds, so always ask before pointing a camera at people. Cash is both practical and preferred; haggling is not a norm in established shops. Modest dress is appreciated in more conservative areas.

Explore Ohio stores on the map

Click markers to view store details. Use filters to show specific store types.

Listing quality snapshot

Phone numbers: 47 of 47
Websites: 46 of 47
Mapped listings: 47 of 47
Source-backed notes: 38 of 47

Plan your Amish getaway

Where locals shop

Millersburg

The largest clusters are around Millersburg, Sugarcreek, Mansfield with 3 listings.

Standout experiences

Bulk Foods Store

15 shops specialise in bulk foods store, alongside farm market, general market.

Trip timing

Year-round access

Most stores welcome visitors year-round, so you can plan a relaxed itinerary in any season.

Browse by store type

Bulk Foods Store (15) Farm Market (9) General Market (8) Specialty Store (7) Bakery (6) Furniture Store (2)

Top towns to explore

Millersburg 3 stores
Sugarcreek 3 stores
Mansfield 2 stores
Montpelier 2 stores
Pataskala 2 stores

Signature finds

jams
jellies
butters
dry foods
candies
cold meats

Specialty Store Verified

Mrs. Miller’s Homemade Jams

Ohio, OH

7919 Co Rd 201, Ohio, OH

Homemade jams by Mrs. Miller

jams

Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.3 Google rating