Step 1
Name the item you need
Ask about the product, size, material, or pattern you want. A broad category such as crafts or quilts does not tell you what is currently on the shelf.
Ohio directory
Amish Specialty Stores in Ohio
Compare 7 listings across 7 towns. Open each store page to confirm current hours, products, payment options, and directions before traveling.
Listings
7
Public record matches
7
Mapped listings
7
Marked seasonal
0
Towns with specialty stores
Products mentioned in listings
- jams
- Handcrafted items
- Traditional goods
- jellies
- butters
- Amish groceries
- meats
- baked goods
Directory categories and product notes describe the current listing data; they are not guarantees of inventory, ownership, or business hours.
Plan a better shopping route
Compare specialty stores with a purpose
A useful route starts with the product or service you need, then narrows the listings by location and current business details. These checks are specific to this store category.
Step 2
Ask about materials and makers
If handmade, local, or a particular maker matters, ask for details about the individual item. Do not infer its origin from the store name.
Step 3
Check orders and returns
For personalized or made-to-order goods, confirm the price, lead time, collection or shipping arrangements, and return policy before ordering.
Specialty Stores in Ohio
| Listing | Town | Product detail | Contact options | Record signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mrs. Miller’s Homemade Jams | Fredericksburg | 3 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Yoder's Fine Foods | Gambier | 3 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Walnut Creek Cheeses | Walnut Creek | 4 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Mary Yoders Amish Kitchen | Middlefield | 2 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Shisler’s Cheese House | Orrville | 3 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| The Olde Thyme Pantry | Elida | 5 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Millers Dry Goods | Millersburg | 3 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
Use this table to shortlist pages; open the listing before relying on a product, schedule, or contact detail. A public-record match identifies a business record but does not establish Amish ownership.
Specialty Store Public record matched 💵 Cash / Check Only
Mrs. Miller’s Homemade Jams
Fredericksburg, OH
7919 Co Rd 201, Fredericksburg, OH
Homemade jams by Mrs. Miller
jams Handcrafted items Traditional goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.3 Google rating
View listing
3361 Martinsburg Rd, Gambier, OH
Jams, jellies, and butters made by owners with Amish background
jams jellies butters
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.5 Google rating
View listing
2641 OH-39, Walnut Creek, OH
Offers Amish groceries, meats, baked goods, and cheeses.
Amish groceries meats baked goods cheeses
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
14743 North State Street, Middlefield, OH
Offers Amish restaurant and gift shop.
restaurant gift shop
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.4 Google rating
View listing
55 Kidron Rd, Orrville, OH
Shisler’s Cheese House offers cheeses, chocolates, and home baked goods.
cheeses chocolates home baked goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.6 Google rating
View listing
626 E Main St, Elida, OH
The Olde Thyme Pantry offers a wide variety of cheeses, meats, butter, homemade goods, and deli items.
cheeses meats butter homemade goods
+1 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.9 Google rating
View listing
4500 OH-557, Millersburg, OH
Millers Dry Goods offers fabrics to make your own quilts.
fabrics Handcrafted items Traditional goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
Questions about specialty stores in Ohio
Where can I find Amish specialty stores in Ohio?
The current directory listings are spread across 7 towns. The leading locations in this collection are Elida (1), Fredericksburg (1), Gambier (1), and Middlefield (1). Open the individual listings for addresses and route links.
What products do the Ohio specialty stores listings mention?
The current listing notes mention jams, Handcrafted items, Traditional goods, jellies, and butters. These are directory notes rather than live inventory, so confirm the exact product, quantity, or model before making a special trip.
How current are these Ohio listings?
7 of the 7 listings are connected to matched public business records and 7 have coordinates available for mapping. A record match is not owner verification, and hours, products, payment methods, and operating status can change after a check.
Are all of these businesses Amish-owned?
No ownership claim follows from inclusion in this collection. The directory covers Amish, Mennonite, plain-community, and related country businesses. A name, category, or product range does not by itself establish ownership or who made a particular item.