7919 Co Rd 201, Ohio, OH
Homemade jams by Mrs. Miller
jams
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.3 Google rating
View listing
The Olde Thyme Pantry
Ohio / 626 E Main St, Elida, OH
The Olde Thyme Pantry offers a wide variety of cheeses, meats, butter, homemade goods, and deli items.
Listed hours run daily except Sunday, with a shorter Saturday window. Confirm by phone or website before a trip.
Listing Confidence
- Google Maps verified
- Jun 17, 2026
- Last updated
- Jun 4, 2025
- Phone
- (419) 331-2855
- Website
- http://www.oldethymepantry.coshop4u.com/
- Website status
- active
- Data checks
- generated id, phone formatting, website validation
- Business status
- operational
- Google rating
- 4.9 (143 reviews)
Details are shown only when present in the listing data. Call ahead to confirm hours and availability before making a special trip. View Google Maps listing. Report an update.
About The Olde Thyme Pantry
The Olde Thyme Pantry is a specialty food store in Elida, Ohio, stocking cheeses, meats, butter, homemade goods, and deli items.
Cheeses, meats, and butter
The store carries a range of cheeses and meats alongside butter. These are the kinds of staples bought by weight or by the cut rather than prepackaged in supermarket portions, which suits cooking for a larger household or stocking up on a regular trip.
Deli items and homemade goods
A deli section handles prepared and sliced items, and the store also stocks homemade goods. Between the deli counter, the cheeses and meats, and the homemade selection, the pantry works as a single stop for both ingredients and ready-to-eat food.
Hours and payment
Posted hours are 9AM to 6PM. Payment is cash only; there is no card option noted here, so plan to bring enough for what you intend to buy.
Contact Information
Store Details
Type Specialty Store
Size small
Seasonal No
Products
cheeses meats butter homemade goods deli items
Frequently Asked Questions
What does The Olde Thyme Pantry carry?
It lists cheeses, meats, butter, homemade goods, and deli items.
Is it open on Sundays?
The listed hours show it closed on Sunday and open the rest of the week.
What payment methods are accepted?
The record lists cash.
What payment methods does The Olde Thyme Pantry accept?
Most Amish stores including The Olde Thyme Pantry primarily accept cash. We recommend calling ahead at (419) 331-2855 to confirm current payment options. Some locations may also accept checks from local customers.
What are the hours of operation for The Olde Thyme Pantry?
The Olde Thyme Pantry is open: 9AM – 6PM. Like most Amish businesses, it is closed on Sundays for religious observance. Call (419) 331-2855 to confirm seasonal hours.
What products can I find at The Olde Thyme Pantry?
The Olde Thyme Pantry offers cheeses, meats, butter, homemade goods, deli items. The Olde Thyme Pantry offers a wide variety of cheeses, meats, butter, homemade goods, and deli items.
Related Stores
3361 Martinsburg Rd, Gambier, OH
Jams, jellies, and butters made by owners with Amish background
jams jellies butters
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.5 Google rating
View listing
728 N Main St, Marysville, OH
Offers a variety of dry foods, candies, cold meats, cheeses, and donuts on Saturday mornings.
dry foods candies cold meats cheeses
+1 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped
View listing