Step 1
Check the baking day
Opening hours do not tell you when a particular bread or pastry will be ready. Ask whether your chosen item is made on the day you plan to visit and whether it can be held for pickup.
Ohio directory
Amish Bakeries in Ohio
Compare 6 listings across 6 towns. Open each store page to confirm current hours, products, payment options, and directions before traveling.
Listings
6
Public record matches
6
Mapped listings
6
Marked seasonal
0
Towns with bakeries
Products mentioned in listings
- Amish meats
- cheeses
- pies
- fresh fruits and vegetables
- organic groceries
- organic produce
- organic eggs
- milk
Directory categories and product notes describe the current listing data; they are not guarantees of inventory, ownership, or business hours.
Plan a better shopping route
Compare bakeries with a purpose
A useful route starts with the product or service you need, then narrows the listings by location and current business details. These checks are specific to this store category.
Step 2
Ask about orders before a gathering
For several pies, a cake, or a larger bread order, confirm the quantity, order deadline, pickup window, and final price directly with the bakery.
Step 3
Plan the trip home
Ask about ingredients, packaging, and storage instructions for your purchase. If dietary requirements matter, discuss the specific product with the bakery before ordering.
Bakeries in Ohio
| Listing | Town | Product detail | Contact options | Record signal |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sterling's Amish Deli | Bowling Green | 3 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Krieger’s Health Foods Market | Cuyahoga Falls | 7 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Covered Wagon Farm Market | Englewood | 6 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| The Dutch Cupboard | Columbiana | 5 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Miller's Bakery | Millersburg | 10 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
| Troyer's Home Pantry | Apple Creek | 6 named categories | Phone + Website | Public record matched |
Use this table to shortlist pages; open the listing before relying on a product, schedule, or contact detail. A public-record match identifies a business record but does not establish Amish ownership.
133 E Wooster St, Bowling Green, OH
Sterling’s Amish Deli offers Amish meats, cheeses, pies and more.
Amish meats cheeses pies
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.6 Google rating
View listing
Bakery Public record matched đź’µ Cash / Check Only
Krieger’s Health Foods Market
Cuyahoga Falls, OH
615 Graham Rd, Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Krieger’s Health Foods Market offers fresh fruits and vegetables, organic groceries, organic produce and organic eggs, milk, cheeses, and Amish pies.
fresh fruits and vegetables organic groceries organic produce organic eggs
+3 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.5 Google rating
View listing
607 N Main St, Englewood, OH
Covered Wagon Farm Market offers produce, bulk spices, cheese, homemade pies, cakes, and bread.
produce bulk spices cheese homemade pies
+2 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
14895 South Ave A, Columbiana, OH
The Dutch Cupboard offers deli meats, pies, bread, a large selection of spices and candies.
deli meats pies bread spices
+1 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
4250 Township Hwy 356, Millersburg, OH
Miller's Bakery in Millersburg, OH. Documented offerings include donuts, fritters, bread, pies, and cookies. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.
Donuts Fritters Bread Pies
+6 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
668 W Main St, Apple Creek, OH
Troyer's Home Pantry in Apple Creek, OH. Documented offerings include pies, cinnamon rolls, cakes, cookies, and bread. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.
Pies Cinnamon rolls Cakes Cookies
+2 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
Questions about bakeries in Ohio
Where can I find Amish bakeries in Ohio?
The current directory listings are spread across 6 towns. The leading locations in this collection are Apple Creek (1), Bowling Green (1), Columbiana (1), and Cuyahoga Falls (1). Open the individual listings for addresses and route links.
What products do the Ohio bakeries listings mention?
The current listing notes mention Amish meats, cheeses, pies, fresh fruits and vegetables, and organic groceries. These are directory notes rather than live inventory, so confirm the exact product, quantity, or model before making a special trip.
How current are these Ohio listings?
6 of the 6 listings are connected to matched public business records and 6 have coordinates available for mapping. A record match is not owner verification, and hours, products, payment methods, and operating status can change after a check.
Are all of these businesses Amish-owned?
No ownership claim follows from inclusion in this collection. The directory covers Amish, Mennonite, plain-community, and related country businesses. A name, category, or product range does not by itself establish ownership or who made a particular item.