NY directory
Browse 17 Amish stores, markets, and shops in New York. Compare contact details, towns, store types, products, and route-planning notes before you visit.
New York is home to one of the largest and most diverse Amish populations in the United States, with approximately 25,000 Amish residents spread across more than a dozen counties. The state's settlements range from long-established communities in the western and central regions to newer, more conservative groups that have migrated from Ohio and Pennsylvania seeking affordable farmland. New York's Amish population has grown steadily over the past three decades, making it a top-five state by Amish population.
The geography of New York Amish country is remarkably varied. St. Lawrence County in the far north — particularly around Canton, Heuvelton, and Ogdensburg — hosts conservative Old Order communities. Cattaraugus County in the southwest has well-established settlements near Conewango Valley and Cherry Creek, known for producing high-quality furniture and dairy products. Madison County around Cazenovia and Schoharie County communities round out a patchwork of settlements scattered across the state's rural interior.
The Penn Yan area in Yates County (Finger Lakes region) is one of the most accessible and visitor-friendly Amish communities in New York. Located near Keuka Lake, this community has been present since the early 19th century and offers a range of roadside stands, bulk food stores, and craft shops.
The Conewango Valley settlement in Cattaraugus County is among the most active for commerce, with a concentration of woodworking shops, bulk food stores, and small farm operations accessible via rural county roads. The community there tends toward traditional Old Order practices, with horse-drawn equipment visible in fields throughout the growing season.
St. Lawrence County communities around Heuvelton draw visitors from northern New York and Canada due to their proximity to the Canadian border and the scenic St. Lawrence River valley. The Madison County and Schoharie County communities serve primarily local and regional customers, making them less commercially developed but authentically representative of everyday Amish life.
Late spring through early fall (May through October) is the optimal window for visiting New York Amish communities. Many home-based businesses and roadside stands operate seasonally, and farm stands peak during the harvest months of August and September. The Finger Lakes area around Penn Yan combines Amish shopping with winery tourism, making September and October particularly rewarding. Winter visits to northern communities like those in St. Lawrence County can involve severe road conditions.
New York's Amish communities are predominantly Old Order Amish, maintaining a conservative lifestyle. The conservatism of many New York settlements — particularly those in St. Lawrence and Cattaraugus counties — reflects the preferences of groups that migrated specifically to maintain stricter practices than communities in more heavily visited states. Visitors should approach interactions with patience and respect: polite conversation is welcome, but discussions probing religious doctrine or pressing for photographs are considered intrusive.
Click markers to view store details. Use filters to show specific store types.
New York
The largest clusters are around New York, Penn Yan, Philadelphia with 3 listings.
Bulk Foods Store
9 shops specialise in bulk foods store, alongside farm market, general market.
Year-round access
Most stores welcome visitors year-round, so you can plan a relaxed itinerary in any season.
Browse New York Amish store listings for farm markets, country stores, bulk foods, baked goods, and specialty stops.
53 Park Place (btwn W. Broadway & Church St), New York, NY
New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.
8220 NY-289, Belleville, NY
Sharps Bulk Foods offers bulk foods and groceries.
10858 Ridge Rd, Medina, NY
Miller’s Bulk Food and Bakery offers bulk foods and baked goods.
7967 US-20, Madison, NY
Offers bulk foods, flours, sugars, spices, seasonings, oats, and various flavorings/extracts.
697 CR 6, Moira, NY
Offers bulk foods and groceries.
5673 State Route 20a E, Warsaw, NY
Offers bulk foods.
386 NY-14, Penn Yan, NY
Offers Amish style quilts.
2146 River Rd, Seneca Falls, NY
Offers meats, baked goods, produce, salsas, jams, jellies, and spices.
6505 NY-5, Vernon, NY
Offers market style goods.
1604 Grand Ave building 2, Savannah, NY
Offers fabrics, bulk foods, and some groceries.
240 East 45th St (btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.
3173 Route 14A, Penn Yan, NY
Amish made cheeses from Ohio communities among a range of non-Amish products.
32660 Rt. 11 S, Philadelphia, NY
Full line of Pennsylvania Dutch products including some Amish made goods.
4086 NY-206, Bainbridge, NY
Offers baking and cooking supplies, high quality spices, flours, sugars, and traditional Amish-style canned goods.
731 9th Ave, New York, NY
Amish Market is a bulk foods store in New York, NY.
32672 US-11, Philadelphia, NY
Martin's Country Store Philadelphia is a bulk foods store in Philadelphia, NY.
Cover multiple communities in a single trip and enjoy the food, craftsmanship, and hospitality that make New York's Amish heritage unique.
View all New York listingsAmish stores in New York are concentrated in several distinct regions. In western New York, Cattaraugus County (Conewango Valley, Cherry Creek, Leon) has a high density of woodworking shops, bulk food stores, and farm stands. The Penn Yan area in Yates County (Finger Lakes) has roadside stands and a well-known bulk food store accessible from Route 14A. St. Lawrence County in northern New York (Heuvelton, Ogdensburg area) has harness shops, produce stands, and small home-based businesses.
The closest Amish communities to Buffalo are in Cattaraugus County, roughly 60–75 miles southeast of the city near Conewango Valley, Cherry Creek, and Leon. For Rochester, the closest communities are in Yates County (Penn Yan area), approximately 55 miles south, and there are also smaller settlements in Livingston and Wyoming counties.
Penn Yan, the county seat of Yates County in the Finger Lakes region, serves as the closest town to one of New York's more accessible Amish communities. The area around Penn Yan has been home to Amish families since the early 19th century. Visitors come specifically for the bulk food stores stocked with dry goods, spices, and baking supplies, as well as farm stands offering seasonal produce, eggs, and baked goods. The location is convenient because Penn Yan has lodging, restaurants, and proximity to Keuka Lake wineries.
Yes, New York Amish communities generally welcome respectful visitors who come to shop or learn. Communities in Cattaraugus County and Yates County are the most visitor-friendly. Northern communities in St. Lawrence County are more conservative and less commercially oriented toward tourism, but individual shops and stands still serve outside customers. Most commerce happens at small home-based shops, requiring visitors to explore rural roads and watch for signs rather than visiting a commercial district.
