7967 US-20, Madison, NY
Offers bulk foods, flours, sugars, spices, seasonings, oats, and various flavorings/extracts.
bulk foods flours sugars spices
+4 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.9 Google rating
View listing
Curated list
Best Amish Stores in New York
Browse New York Amish store listings for farm markets, country stores, bulk foods, baked goods, and specialty stops.
15 Top Picks
How we select the best
Rankings consider listing completeness, contact information, product variety, map data, and overall usefulness. The top 3 are highlighted with numbered badges.
1
2
2146 River Rd, Seneca Falls, NY
Offers meats, baked goods, produce, salsas, jams, jellies, and spices.
meats baked goods produce salsas
+3 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
3
4086 NY-206, Bainbridge, NY
Offers baking and cooking supplies, high quality spices, flours, sugars, and traditional Amish-style canned goods.
groceries baking supplies cooking supplies high quality spices
+3 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
53 Park Place (btwn W. Broadway & Church St), New York, NY
New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.
foods fresh produce baked goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4 Google rating
View listing
1604 Grand Ave building 2, Savannah, NY
Offers fabrics, bulk foods, and some groceries.
fabrics bulk foods groceries
Phone listed Website repaired Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
240 East 45th St (btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY
New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.
foods fresh produce baked goods groceries
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.4 Google rating
View listing
3173 Route 14A, Penn Yan, NY
Amish made cheeses from Ohio communities among a range of non-Amish products.
cheeses bulk foods groceries
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
32660 Rt. 11 S, Philadelphia, NY
Full line of Pennsylvania Dutch products including some Amish made goods.
Pennsylvania Dutch products Amish made goods bulk foods deli items
+1 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
8220 NY-289, Belleville, NY
Sharps Bulk Foods offers bulk foods and groceries.
bulk foods groceries
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
10858 Ridge Rd, Medina, NY
Miller’s Bulk Food and Bakery offers bulk foods and baked goods.
bulk foods baked goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
697 CR 6, Moira, NY
Offers bulk foods and groceries.
bulk foods groceries
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
5673 State Route 20a E, Warsaw, NY
Offers bulk foods.
bulk foods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
386 NY-14, Penn Yan, NY
Offers Amish style quilts.
Amish style quilts
Phone listed Website listed Mapped
View listing
6505 NY-5, Vernon, NY
Offers market style goods.
market style goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
Tips for visiting
- New York Amish shopping areas are spread across multiple rural regions, so plan by town cluster.
- Farm markets, country stores, and bulk foods are strong route anchors.
- Weather and seasonality can affect rural travel, especially outside summer and fall.
- Amish-owned stores are closed on Sundays. Plan your visit for Monday through Saturday and call ahead before a long drive.