New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.
The market is open seven days a week into the evening; confirm current hours by phone or on its website before visiting.
Hours and availability should be confirmed before visiting. View Google Maps listing. Report an update. Own this business? How verification works.
Page-specific directory evidence
Amish Market (East) is recorded at 240 East 45th St (btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY and classified as farm market. Its directory record specifically names foods, fresh produce, baked goods, and groceries. 1 other indexable listing is available in New York for comparison.
A farm market in New York City supplying Amish products, the store carries a broad grocery line: general foods, fresh produce, baked goods, and standard pantry groceries.
Fresh produce is stocked alongside baked goods, the two categories most tied to regular turnover. The produce side covers everyday fruits and vegetables; the bakery side covers breads and other baked items. Both suit shoppers buying for near-term use rather than long storage, and they pair with the wider grocery and food selection if you are filling a full cart in one stop.
Beyond retail, the market runs an Amish-style restaurant and offers catering and delivery. The restaurant serves prepared food on site; catering extends that to larger orders for events; delivery brings groceries or food to you rather than requiring a trip in. The combination makes the location usable as a sit-down stop, an order-ahead source, or a place to shop in person.
Payment is by cash or check; no card option is noted, so plan to bring one of those. Given the New York City setting, the long hours make it easier to fit a visit around a work schedule than a market with a narrow midday window would.
Farm-market inventory follows weather, harvest timing, and the individual vendors or growers supplying the stand. Ask what is currently in season rather than relying on an older photo or review. Bring a cooler for eggs, dairy, meat, or other refrigerated purchases, and confirm the operating season before making a long drive.
This page records the business name, location, category, and available contact or product details from the sources shown above. A Google Maps match or country-style business name does not by itself establish Amish ownership, who made every product, or what is in stock today. For those distinctions, ask the business about the specific item or relationship that matters to you. If you find an outdated address, closure, or product claim, use the listing correction form so the record can be reviewed.
Recorded product offerings. Call ahead to confirm seasonal stock.
Advertisement
It carries foods, fresh produce, baked goods, and groceries, plus an Amish-style restaurant with catering and delivery.
The listing notes cash and check.
It is at 240 E 45th St, New York, NY 10017.
Amish Market (East) is listed at 240 East 45th St (btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY. Use the directions link and confirm the address with the business before a long trip.
Amish Market (East) is categorized in this directory as Farm Market. Category labels describe the documented store format and do not by themselves establish ownership or where every item was made.
The current directory record mentions foods, fresh produce, baked goods, and groceries. Availability can change, so confirm the specific item and quantity before traveling.
Monday: 7AM-9:30PM; Tuesday: 7AM-9:30PM; Wednesday: 7AM-9:30PM; Thursday: 7AM-9:30PM; Friday: 7AM-9:30PM; Saturday: 8AM-9:30PM; Sunday: 8AM-9:30PM. Hours from a saved public record checked Jun 17, 2026. Confirm the current schedule before visiting.
731 9th Ave, New York, NY
Amish Market in New York, NY. Documented offerings include bagels, soup, salads, sandwiches, and wraps. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.
239 Buffalo Ave, Paterson, NJ
Okyanus Market is listed in Paterson, NJ. Its current product range has not been independently confirmed. Check the available contact information before traveling for a specific item.
Princeton, NJ
4437 Route 27, Princeton, NJ
Home to Beiler’s dairy, Smoker’s deli, Stoltzfus’ poultry and soft pretzels, Fisher’s bakery, K & R lunch counter, fresh produce, juices and more.
