📍

Amish Stores in New York, NY

Discover authentic Amish businesses in New York, New York.

2 Stores Found

Plan your visit to New York

What you'll find

Farm Market

2 listings in this category lead the way.

Signature finds

foods

Shoppers love foods, fresh produce, baked goods. Small-batch quality at every stop.

Trip timing

Year-round access

Most stores here welcome visitors year-round, so you can plan a visit whenever it suits you.

Browse by store type

Farm Market (2)

What shoppers find here

foods
fresh produce
baked goods
groceries

🧺 Farm Market

Amish Market (Tribeca)

53 Park Place (btwn W. Broadway & Church St), New York, NY

New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.

foods fresh produce baked goods

(212) 608-3863

Website

View Details

🧺 Farm Market

Amish Market (East)

240 East 45th St (btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY

New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.

foods fresh produce baked goods groceries

(212) 370-1761

Website

View Details

Explore more of New York

New York is one of many Amish communities in New York. Browse the full state directory to plan a longer trip.

View all New York listings

Travel tips for New York

Start early on weekdays—many Amish businesses in New York close by mid-afternoon and are closed on Sundays.
Look for foods and fresh produce—local favorites that tend to sell out by noon.
Bring cash and reusable bags. Most Amish stores prefer cash payments and appreciate shoppers who come prepared.

Frequently asked questions

What kinds of Amish stores are in New York, NY?

New York has 2 farm markets. Common finds include foods, fresh produce, baked goods.

When are the Amish stores in New York open?

Stores in New York are generally open Monday through Saturday, 8am–5pm. Amish businesses are always closed on Sundays.

How do I get to the Amish stores in New York?

New York, New York is accessible by car. Use the "Get Directions" button on each store listing below for turn-by-turn navigation. Bring cash as many stores don't accept cards.