Amish Stores in New York, NY

Browse Amish and plain-community store listings in New York, New York.

3 Stores Found

New York rural bulk food shop exterior in a village setting — Editorial regional image for trip planning, not a photo of a specific listed business.

Plan your visit to New York

What you will find

Farm Market

2 listings in this category lead the way, plus bulk foods store.

Listing notes

foods

Directory listings for this city mention foods, fresh produce, baked goods. Check individual store pages before you drive.

Trip timing

Call ahead

Hours can be limited and many Amish-owned businesses close on Sundays, so confirm details before you travel.

Browse by store type

Farm Market (2) Bulk Foods Store (1)

What listings mention here

foods
fresh produce
baked goods
groceries

Farm Market Verified Closed

Amish Market (Tribeca)

New York, NY

53 Park Place (btwn W. Broadway & Church St), New York, NY

New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.

foods fresh produce baked goods

Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4 Google rating

View listing

Farm Market Verified

Amish Market (East)

New York, NY

240 East 45th St (btwn 2nd Ave & 3rd Ave), New York, NY

New York City supplier for Amish products, carrying all kind of foods, fresh produce and baked goods. Amish style restaurant, catering and delivery available.

foods fresh produce baked goods groceries

Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.4 Google rating

View listing

Bulk Foods Store Verified

Amish Market

New York, NY

731 9th Ave, New York, NY

Amish Market is a bulk foods store in New York, NY.

Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.4 Google rating

View listing

Explore more of New York

New York is one of many communities in New York. Browse the full state directory to plan a longer trip.

View all New York listings

Travel tips for New York

Start early on weekdays; many Amish and plain-community businesses close earlier than chain retailers and are closed on Sundays.
Use the product notes to prioritize stops for foods and fresh produce.
Bring cash and reusable bags. Many small stores prefer cash payments and appreciate shoppers who come prepared.

Frequently asked questions

What kinds of Amish stores are in New York, NY?

New York has 2 farm markets, 1 bulk foods store. Common listing notes include foods, fresh produce, baked goods.

When are the Amish stores in New York open?

Stores in New York are generally open Monday through Saturday with limited local hours. Amish-owned businesses are closed on Sundays.

How do I get to the Amish stores in New York?

New York, New York is accessible by car. Use the directions link on each store listing for navigation and confirm the address before you travel.