Curated list
Indiana's Amish communities include Shipshewana, Nappanee, and other towns with strong store, market, and furniture listings.
Rankings consider listing completeness, contact information, product variety, map data, and overall usefulness. The top 3 are highlighted with numbered badges.
13014 N 1100 E, Odon, IN
Amish-run business, provides homemade products such as bulk foods, deli meats, cheeses, sandwiches, candies, jar goods, baked goods and crafts.
6747 E Gasthof Village Rd, Montgomery, IN
Gasthof Amish Village is located in Southern Indiana. In the 92-acre village you will find a restaurant, antiques, gift shop and hotel. Gasthof’s buffet offers authentic food made by Amish women. The gift shop features Amish produce, crafts and food.
11334 Page Rd, Grabill, IN
Specializes in bulk seasonings, medicinal/culinary herbs, loose-leaf teas, baking ingredients, and kitchen accessories.
1265 IN-5, Shipshewana, IN
Old-fashioned deli & market selling sandwiches & ice cream, plus bulk goods from candy to spices.
107 Keystone Drive, Wakarusa, IN
Amish store with homemade foods, meats and deli, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement.
195 North Van Buren Street, Shipshewana, IN
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery offers Family-owned country kitchen & bakery open all day alongside an Amish crafts marketplace.
5129 Illinois Rd #101, Fort Wayne, IN
Rise’n Roll Bakery offers Amish baked goods and famous cinnamon caramel donuts.
100 Madison St, Decatur, IN
Decatur Farmers Market offers local grown products.
4626 900 E, Montgomery, IN
The Country Cupboard offers baked goods.
P.O. Box 6122, Auburn, IN
Downtown Auburn Farmer’s Market offers local products including Amish Graber Farms’ fresh certified organic produce.
817 DuPont Road, Fort Wayne, IN
Organic Amish grown products among a large assortment of non-Amish items.
9622 West 350 North, Orland, IN
Small family-owned company, provides poultry raised by Amish families in small flocks.
1720 E 256th St, Arcadia, IN
Amish market with a variety of products
1140 Whitewater Rd, Fountain City, IN
Highly recommended Amish market near Richmond, Indiana
9564 IN-67, Worthington, IN
An Amish store with decent prices, recently expanded.
