🎁 Specialty Store
Grandma’s Pantry
107 Keystone Drive, Wakarusa, IN
Amish store with homemade foods, meats and deli, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement.
homemade foods meats deli
(574) 862-1959
Website
📍
Best Amish Stores in Indiana
Indiana's Elkhart and LaGrange counties host thriving Amish communities. Browse the best Amish stores in Shipshewana and beyond.
15 Top Picks
How we select the best
Our rankings consider the completeness of each listing — detailed descriptions, contact information, product variety, and overall listing quality. All stores are authentic Amish businesses. The top 3 are highlighted with numbered badges.
1
2
🥖 Bakery
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
195 North Van Buren Street, Shipshewana, IN
Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery offers Family-owned country kitchen & bakery open all day alongside an Amish crafts marketplace.
country kitchen bakery Amish crafts
(260) 768-4725
Website
3
🧂 Bulk Foods Store
Dutch Pantry
13014 N 1100 E, Odon, IN
Amish-run business, provides homemade products such as bulk foods, deli meats, cheeses, sandwiches, candies, jar goods, baked goods and crafts.
bulk foods deli meats cheeses sandwiches
+7 more
(812) 636-7922
Website
🧺 Farm Market
Gasthof Amish Village
6747 E Gasthof Village Rd, Montgomery, IN
Gasthof Amish Village is located in Southern Indiana. In the 92-acre village you will find a restaurant, antiques, gift shop and hotel. Gasthof’s buffet offers authentic food made by Amish women. The gift shop features Amish produce, crafts and food.
produce crafts food authentic Amish food
+2 more
(812) 486-2600
Website
🧂 Bulk Foods Store
The Spice Shack
11334 Page Rd, Grabill, IN
Specializes in bulk seasonings, medicinal/culinary herbs, loose-leaf teas, baking ingredients, and kitchen accessories.
bulk seasonings medicinal herbs culinary herbs loose-leaf teas
+2 more
Website
🥖 Bakery
Rise’n Roll Bakery
5129 Illinois Rd #101, Fort Wayne, IN
Rise’n Roll Bakery offers Amish baked goods and famous cinnamon caramel donuts.
baked goods cinnamon caramel donuts
(260) 436-5695
Website
🧺 Farm Market
Decatur Farmers Market
100 Madison St, Decatur, IN
Decatur Farmers Market offers local grown products.
local grown products
(260) 724-2604
Website
🧂 Bulk Foods Store
E & S Sales Bulk Foods
1265 IN-5, Shipshewana, IN
Old-fashioned deli & market selling sandwiches & ice cream, plus bulk goods from candy to spices.
sandwiches ice cream bulk goods candy
+1 more
(260) 768-4736
Website
🎁 Specialty Store
The Country Cupboard
4626 900 E, Montgomery, IN
The Country Cupboard offers baked goods.
baked goods
(812) 486-2882
Website
🧺 Farm Market
Salomon Farm Park Market
817 DuPont Road, Fort Wayne, IN
Organic Amish grown products among a large assortment of non-Amish items.
organic Amish grown products
(260) 427-6790
Website
🧺 Farm Market
Downtown Auburn Farmer’s Market
P.O. Box 6122, Auburn, IN
Downtown Auburn Farmer’s Market offers local products including Amish Graber Farms’ fresh certified organic produce.
certified organic produce local products
(260) 925-3113
Website
🎁 Specialty Store
Miller Poultry
9622 West 350 North, Orland, IN
Small family-owned company, provides poultry raised by Amish families in small flocks.
poultry
(260) 829-6550
Website
🏪 General Market
Freedom Country Store
9564 IN-67, Worthington, IN
An Amish store with decent prices, recently expanded.
(812) 875-3996
Website
🧺 Farm Market
YLNI Farmers Market
302 E Berry St, Fort Wayne, IN
YLNI Farmers Market offers local grown products including organic produce from Amish-owned Graber’s farm.
organic produce
Website
🧂 Bulk Foods Store
Squirrel Creek Bulk Foods
13653 N 500 E, Roann, IN
(574) 893-1942
Website
Tips for visiting
- Shipshewana is Indiana's Amish shopping hub — the flea market runs Tuesdays and Wednesdays.
- Nappanee is another great base for furniture workshops and bakeries.
- The area is known for excellent bulk food stores stocked with Amish-made products.
- Amish stores are always closed on Sundays — plan your visit for Monday through Saturday.