Amish store with homemade foods, meats and deli, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement.
Discover Authentic Amish Charm at Grandma’s Pantry in Wakarusa, Indiana
Tucked away in the heart of northern Indiana’s peaceful countryside lies a hidden gem brimming with Amish charm: Grandma’s Pantry. This small specialty store, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement, offers visitors a unique opportunity to step into a world of homemade goodness and traditional craftsmanship. Whether you’re a curious tourist exploring Amish culture for the first time or a local seeking wholesome, fresh ingredients, Grandma’s Pantry delivers the authentic flavors and warm hospitality that make Amish businesses so beloved.
Conveniently situated behind Subway on SR 19, Grandma’s Pantry is unassuming in its exterior but rich in its offerings. From the moment you step through the door, you’re greeted by the unmistakable aroma of homemade baked goods and fresh deli meats—a sensory welcome that feels like stepping into your grandmother’s kitchen. This is not just a store; it’s an experience, a slice of Amish life that invites you to slow down, savor the moment, and indulge in the simple pleasures of quality food made with care.
Whether you’re seeking delectable homemade foods, exploring Amish culture, or simply looking for a quiet escape, Grandma’s Pantry is a must-visit destination. This small specialty store in Wakarusa, Indiana, embodies the charm, craftsmanship, and flavor of Amish traditions, offering visitors an authentic taste of the heartland. From the friendly staff to the irresistible baked goods, every detail of your visit promises to leave a lasting impression. Come for the jam, stay for the experience—and leave with a deeper appreciation for the simple joys of Amish life.
Most Amish stores including Grandma’s Pantry primarily accept cash. We recommend calling ahead at (574) 862-1959 to confirm current payment options. Some locations may also accept checks from local customers.
Hours can vary by season and day of the week. Please call (574) 862-1959 to confirm current hours before visiting. Most Amish stores are closed on Sundays for religious observance.
Grandma’s Pantry offers homemade foods, meats, deli. Amish store with homemade foods, meats and deli, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement.
Grandma’s Pantry is open year-round, but we recommend calling (574) 862-1959 to confirm hours before making a special trip.
1025 N. Western Ave. Chicago. Illinois, Shipshewana, IN
Small family business operated by a mother and daughter. They carry a wide selection of Amish products from Shipshewana community in Indiana.
Corner Wayne and Barr Streets, Fort Wayne, IN
Large selection of local grown products including organic produce from Amish-owned Graber’s farm.
231 East Monroe Street, Decatur, IN
Organic produce from Graber’s farm available. Located near the Adams County Amish settlement.
