Skip to main content

Indiana directory

Amish Specialty Stores in Indiana

Compare 4 listings across 4 towns. Open each store page to confirm current hours, products, payment options, and directions before traveling.

Listings

4

Public record matches

3

Mapped listings

4

Marked seasonal

0

Towns with specialty stores

Products mentioned in listings

  • natural fed/free-range meats
  • cheeses
  • raw products
  • organic milk
  • eggs
  • organic fruits and vegetables
  • cookies
  • candy

Directory categories and product notes describe the current listing data; they are not guarantees of inventory, ownership, or business hours.

Plan a better shopping route

Specialty Stores in Indiana

Specialty Store

Amish Healthy Foods

Shipshewana, IN

1025 N. Western Ave. Chicago. Illinois, Shipshewana, IN

Small family business operated by a mother and daughter. They carry a wide selection of Amish products from Shipshewana community in Indiana.

natural fed/free-range meats cheeses raw products organic milk +5 more
Specialty Store Public record matched

The Country Cupboard

Montgomery, IN

4626 900 E, Montgomery, IN

The Country Cupboard offers baked goods.

baked goods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
Specialty Store Public record matched

Grandma’s Pantry

Wakarusa, IN

107 Keystone Drive, Wakarusa, IN

Amish store with homemade foods, meats and deli, located in the Nappanee Amish settlement.

homemade foods meats deli
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
Specialty Store Public record matched

Miller Poultry

Orland, IN

9622 West 350 North, Orland, IN

Small family-owned company, provides poultry raised by Amish families in small flocks.

poultry
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.4 Google rating
View listing