Best Amish Specialty Stores

Amish Healthy Foods offers honey, grass fed beef and chicken, Organic fruits, veggies, meats, and dairies.

Amish farm market, locally owned and operated by Elam & Naomi Fisher, features homemade root beer, baked goods, home canned preserves, and handcrafted gifts.

Carries broad selection of Amish products including fruit butter, meats, cheeses, Amish Wedding foods, granola and noodles.

Offers baking and cooking supplies, high quality spices, flours, sugars, and traditional Amish-style canned goods.

Specializes in a variety of meats including custom cut, smoked meats and sausages.

A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.

Amish House carries a broad choice of items including popcorn, syrups and Amish cheeses.

Yoder’s Gift Shoppe offers Amish food, cheese, butter, jewelry, and kitchenware.

John’s Amish Country offers Amish grown vegetables, fruit, and eggs.

Baba Bazaar offers local fruits, vegetables, and lots of dried foods.

Colorado City Creamery offers unique flavors of ice cream, plus hot dogs, shakes, cakes & an outdoor patio.

Offers a restaurant, bakery and coffee shop.

Floyd’s Harvest Foods offers grocery store, fresh veggies, great meat section.

Homestyle Foods offers spices, pasta, rice and flour in bulk.

Karen’s Country Kitchen offers Amish made jellies, jams, jar goods and cheeses as well as many locally made products.