Find the top-rated Amish bakeries across the country, known for freshly baked breads, pies, cookies, and pastries made with traditional recipes.
Our rankings consider the completeness of each listing — detailed descriptions, contact information, product variety, and overall listing quality. All stores are authentic Amish businesses. The top 3 are highlighted with numbered badges.
3040 Highway 65 North, Dermott, AR
Offers Amish and Mennonite made fresh bread, jams, snacks, cheeses and meats, fruit cider, candy, cookbooks, soaps and more.
133 Foss Rd, Ava, IL
Shawnee Country Store offers lunch meats, homemade bread, cinnamon rolls and yummy candies meats and cheeses.
9701 Fort Meade Rd, Laurel, MD
Dutch Country Farmer’s Market offers fresh produce, meats, sweets, homemade desserts, pickles, pies, bread, and cooked goods.
3356 Underwood Rd, Oakland, MD
Schrock’s Country Store offers homemade soups, sandwiches, bread, sticky buns, jellies, spices, noodles, and furniture.
27 Wildlife Rd, Buffalo, MO
Schrocks Country Store offers home baked goods, james, jellies, pie fillings, meat, cheeses, and more.
615 Graham Rd, Cuyahoga Falls, OH
Krieger’s Health Foods Market offers fresh fruits and vegetables, organic groceries, organic produce and organic eggs, milk, cheeses, and Amish pies.
607 N Main St, Englewood, OH
Covered Wagon Farm Market offers produce, bulk spices, cheese, homemade pies, cakes, and bread.
999 Heber Springs Rd South, Heber Springs, AR
Ozark Country Market offers jellies, bread, nuts, cheese curds, goat milk soap and other homemade goods.
905 N. Main Street, Harrison, AR
Homey Hearth Bakery and Deli offers baked goods and deli meats.
701 N Broad Street, Middletown, DE
Dutch Country Farmers Market offers fresh donuts, baked goods, seasonal local produce, fresh meats, chicken, salads, milk and cheeses, crabcakes, and furniture.
1368 Rose Valley School Road, Dover, DE
At Byler's variety store you can find some Amish handcrafted wooden items among a wide choice of foods, meats, pies, cookies, jams and jellies and more.
415 Perrytown Road, Scottsville, KY
Located in the Amish community in Allen County, KY. Wide array of local products available.
206 13th Street SW, Largo, FL
The Amish Country Store has been in business for over 10 years. They carry a broad choice of products including Amish butter, Amish cheeses, meats, Bird-In-Hand and Wixon shoofly pies, soda and rootbeer.
259 N CR 200E, Arthur, IL
Beachy’s Bulk Foods offers Amish homemade pastries, fresh pies, flours, spices, candy and groceries.
1195 E. Columbia, Arthur, IL
Yoder’s Kitchen offers Amish home meals & a buffet, plus a gift shop with Amish goods.
