Amish Store Locator logo Amish Store Locator

Amish Stores in Colorado

Discover 12 authentic Amish stores, markets, and shops in Colorado. Find handcrafted furniture, fresh baked goods, farm-fresh produce, and traditional crafts.

12 Stores Found

📍 Explore Colorado Stores on Map

Showing 8 of 12 stores on map

Click markers to view store details ‱ Use filters to show specific store types

Plan your Amish getaway

Where locals shop

Monte Vista

The largest clusters are around Monte Vista, Colorado Springs, Calhan with 4 listings.

Standout experiences

Specialty Store

4 shops specialise in specialty store, alongside bakery, farm market.

Trip timing

Year-round access

Most stores welcome visitors year-round, so you can plan a relaxed itinerary in any season.

Browse by store type

Specialty Store (4) Bakery (3) Farm Market (3) General Market (2)

Top towns to explore

  • Monte Vista 4 stores
  • Colorado Springs 2 stores
  • Calhan 1 store
  • Delta 1 store
  • Loveland 1 store

Signature finds

  • baked goods
  • dry goods
  • kitchen supplies
  • canning supplies
  • books
  • cards
đŸ„– Bakery

Miller Family Bakery

494 State Highway 370, Monte Vista, CO

Amish owned and operated bakery in San Luis Valley. Run by five Miller daughters.

baked goods
View Details
đŸȘ General Market

Bontrager’s Variety Store

9726 S County Rd 3 E, Monte Vista, CO

Bontrager’s Variety Store offers a variety of dry goods, kitchen & canning supplies, books & cards, off-the-grid resources (solar power, propane appliances), clothing & footwear, cleaning supplies, and hardware items.

dry goods kitchen supplies canning supplies books +7 more
(719) 852-0500
Website
View Details
🎁 Specialty Store

Colorado City Creamery

2602 Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO

Colorado City Creamery offers unique flavors of ice cream, plus hot dogs, shakes, cakes & an outdoor patio.

ice cream hot dogs shakes cakes
(719) 634-1411
Website
View Details
đŸ§ș Farm Market

Esh’s Grocery Market

375 W 71st St, Loveland, CO

Esh’s Grocery Market offers deli, fresh produce, bakery, frozen foods.

deli fresh produce bakery frozen foods
(970) 292-8387
Website
View Details
đŸ§ș Farm Market

Woolsey’s Food Center

474 Colorado Ave, Calhan, CO

Woolsey’s Food Center offers groceries, produce, and fresh/frozen meats.

groceries produce fresh meats frozen meats
(719) 347-2446
Website
View Details
đŸ§ș Farm Market

Heinie’s Market

11801 W 44th Ave, Wheat Ridge, CO

Offers fresh produce, plus flowers, jams & snacks.

fresh produce flowers jams snacks
(303) 425-9955
Website
View Details
🎁 Specialty Store

The Mosca Pit Stop

5305 CO-17, Mosca, CO

Offers a small supply of groceries and other convenience store items.

groceries convenience store items
(719) 378-2346
Website
View Details

Planning a visit to Colorado?

Cover multiple communities in a single trip and enjoy the food, craftsmanship, and hospitality that make Colorado's Amish heritage unique.

View all Colorado listings

Travel tips for Colorado

  • Plan a loop through Monte Vista, Colorado Springs, Calhan to experience different Amish communities without backtracking.
  • Pair a morning stop at a specialty store with an afternoon visit to bakery and farm market for souvenirs and pantry staples.
  • Bring cash and a cooler - many Amish merchants prefer simple payments and fresh goods travel best when kept chilled.

Frequently asked questions

When is the best time to visit Amish stores in Colorado?

Most businesses here operate year-round, making it easy to plan a trip in any season without worrying about closures.

What should I expect to find in Colorado's Amish shops?

Visitors rave about baked goods, dry goods, kitchen supplies. You'll also discover handmade goods, pantry staples, and locally sourced ingredients unique to Colorado.

How can I make the most of a one-day itinerary?

Start near Monte Vista for breakfast, continue toward Colorado Springs and Calhan for lunch and shopping, and leave time for a scenic country drive between stops.