Colorado City Creamery

Colorado · 2602 Colorado Ave, Colorado Springs, CO

Colorado City Creamery offers unique flavors of ice cream, plus hot dogs, shakes, cakes & an outdoor patio.

Last updated: Jun 4, 2025 · Sources: generated_id, phone_formatting, website_validation, business_classification

About This Store

Discover Timeless Treats at Colorado City Creamery in Colorado Springs

Visitor Experience

Nestled in the heart of Colorado Springs, Colorado City Creamery is more than just an ice cream shop—it’s a charming, nostalgic escape where time slows down and simple pleasures reign supreme. This small, specialty store invites locals and visitors alike to savor old-fashioned delights in a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. Whether you’re craving a scoop of handcrafted ice cream, a decadent milkshake, or a bite of something savory, Colorado City Creamery offers a unique experience that combines culinary craftsmanship with the warmth of a community gathering place. With its outdoor patio and classic menu items, this hidden gem has become a beloved destination for families, foodies, and anyone seeking a sweet retreat.

Products & Offerings

A Flavorful Feast for the Senses

Cultural Background

The star of Colorado City Creamery is undoubtedly its ice cream, which comes in a variety of unique flavors that are sure to tantalize your taste buds. Each batch is made with care, capturing the creamy richness and authentic taste of homemade goodness. Whether you prefer classic vanilla and chocolate or adventurous flavors like salted caramel or blackberry swirl, there’s something for every palate here. The ice cream is served in generous portions, perfect for cones, cups, or even piled high between two cookies as an ice cream sandwich.

Planning Your Visit

Whether you’re a local looking for your next favorite hangout or a visitor eager to experience the charm of Colorado Springs, Colorado City Creamery is a must-visit destination. Its handcrafted treats, welcoming atmosphere, and nostalgic appeal make it a place you’ll want to return to again and again. So bring your appetite, grab some cash, and prepare to indulge in the timeless joy of ice cream done right.

Store Details

Type Specialty Store
Size small
Seasonal No

Products

ice cream hot dogs shakes cakes

Share

Help others discover this authentic Amish store

Frequently Asked Questions

What payment methods does Colorado City Creamery accept?

Most Amish stores including Colorado City Creamery primarily accept cash. We recommend calling ahead at (719) 634-1411 to confirm current payment options. Some locations may also accept checks from local customers.

What are the hours of operation for Colorado City Creamery?

Hours can vary by season and day of the week. Please call (719) 634-1411 to confirm current hours before visiting. Most Amish stores are closed on Sundays for religious observance.

What products can I find at Colorado City Creamery?

Colorado City Creamery offers ice cream, hot dogs, shakes, cakes. Colorado City Creamery offers unique flavors of ice cream, plus hot dogs, shakes, cakes & an outdoor patio.

Is Colorado City Creamery open year-round?

Colorado City Creamery is open year-round, but we recommend calling (719) 634-1411 to confirm hours before making a special trip.

Related Stores

đŸ„– Bakery

Miller Family Bakery

494 State Highway 370, Monte Vista, CO

Amish owned and operated bakery in San Luis Valley. Run by five Miller daughters.

baked goods
đŸȘ General Market

Bontrager’s Variety Store

9726 S County Rd 3 E, Monte Vista, CO

Bontrager’s Variety Store offers a variety of dry goods, kitchen & canning supplies, books & cards, off-the-grid resources (solar power, propane appliances), clothing & footwear, cleaning supplies, and hardware items.

dry goods kitchen supplies canning supplies books +7 more
(719) 852-0500
Website
View Details
đŸ§ș Farm Market

Esh’s Grocery Market

375 W 71st St, Loveland, CO

Esh’s Grocery Market offers deli, fresh produce, bakery, frozen foods.

deli fresh produce bakery frozen foods
(970) 292-8387
Website
View Details