Skip to main content

Directory-data shortlist

Best Amish Stores in Wisconsin

Wisconsin's Amish communities span several regions. Discover store listings for furniture, baked goods, markets, bulk foods, and more.

11 verified directory picks
Wisconsin rural dairy road scene for Amish store trip planning
Editorial image for this curated list, not a photo of a specific listed business.

What β€œbest” means in this directory

β€œBest” means the listings with the strongest current directory records, not a claim that a business has the best products, service, or visitor experience.

Eligible listings must be operational in our current data, matched to a public business record, and meet our indexability checks for address, contact, map, and useful listing content. Ordering then considers record completeness, contact information, product notes, and map data. Call ahead because details can change after our most recent check.

General Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Lark Country Store

Shawano, WI

W5431 Lark Rd, Shawano, WI

Lark Country Store in Shawano, WI. Documented offerings include bulk foods, spices, groceries, books and cards, and baby items. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Bulk foods Spices Groceries Books and cards +3 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
General Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Simple Life Country Store

Fort Atkinson, WI

N2795 Ebbert Ln, Fort Atkinson, WI

Simple Life Country Store in Fort Atkinson, WI. Documented offerings include flour, oats, grains, spices, and beans. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Flour Oats Grains Spices +6 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
General Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Kauffmans Country Store

Beloit, WI

9550 WI-81, Beloit, WI

Kauffmans Country Store in Beloit, WI. Documented offerings include spices and baking ingredients, cookies, bread, cinnamon and pecan rolls, and pies. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Spices and baking ingredients Cookies Bread Cinnamon and pecan rolls +6 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing
General Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

The Village Market

Spencer, WI

212 S Pacific St, Spencer, WI

The Village Market in Spencer, WI. Documented offerings include deli meats, cheese, meat, frozen dough, and dairy products. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Deli meats Cheese Meat Frozen dough +4 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
Specialty Store Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Old Country Cheese

Cashton, WI

S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI

A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.

jams jellies cheeses gifts +1 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
General Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Countryside Bent & Dent (Amish Grocery Store)

Albany, WI

363 Atkinson Rd, Albany, WI

Countryside Bent & Dent (Amish Grocery Store) in Albany, WI. Documented offerings include groceries and frozen foods. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Groceries Frozen foods
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
Farm Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Amish Produce Store

Cambria, WI

W4648 Ln 1, Cambria, WI

Amish store specializing in fresh produce.

fresh produce Fresh produce Seasonal fruit
Website listed Mapped 5 Google rating
View listing
General Market Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Mishlers Country Store

Dalton, WI

W5115 Barry Rd, Dalton, WI

Mishlers Country Store in Dalton, WI. Documented offerings include bulk foods, spices, cookbooks, and kitchenware. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Bulk foods Spices Cookbooks Kitchenware
Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating
View listing
Specialty Store Public record matched πŸ’΅ Cash / Check Only

Oak School Amish Shop

Mauston, WI

N4359 County Rd HH, Mauston, WI

Oak School Amish Shop is listed in Mauston, WI. Its current product range has not been independently confirmed. Check the available contact information before traveling for a specific item.

Phone listed Mapped 4.5 Google rating
View listing
Bulk Foods Store Public record matched

Amish House

Westfield, WI

217 N Pioneer Park Rd, Westfield, WI

Amish House is a bulk foods store in Westfield, WI.

Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.5 Google rating
View listing
Bulk Foods Store Public record matched

Brubaker's Country Store (Bulk Foods, Deli)

Oconto, WI

3152 Co Rd A, Oconto, WI

Brubaker's Country Store (Bulk Foods, Deli) in Oconto, WI. Documented offerings include bulk foods, spices, sandwiches, and groceries. Check the linked sources and contact the business for current availability.

Bulk foods Spices Sandwiches Groceries
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.9 Google rating
View listing

Tips for visiting

  • Wisconsin Amish communities are spread out, so build routes by county or nearby town.
  • Furniture, food stores, farm markets, and seasonal goods are common reasons to plan a Wisconsin route.
  • Bring a cooler for cheese, dairy, meats, and bakery stops if your route is more than a short drive.
  • Hours, seasonal schedules, and payment options vary by business. Check the listing source or call ahead before a long drive.