Amish Store Locator logo Amish Store Locator
🎁 Specialty Store

Old Country Cheese

Wisconsin · S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI

A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.

Last updated: Jun 4, 2025 · Sources: generated_id, phone_formatting, website_validation, business_classification

About This Store

Discover Old Country Cheese: A Hidden Gem in Amish Country

Visitor Experience

Nestled in the rolling hills of Cashton, Wisconsin, Old Country Cheese is more than just a market—it’s a window into the timeless traditions of the Amish community. This small specialty store is brimming with handcrafted products and culinary treasures that reflect the simplicity and dedication of a way of life unchanged by modern conveniences. Whether you’re a curious traveler seeking authentic Amish-made goods or a local looking for high-quality, wholesome treats, Old Country Cheese is a must-visit destination that invites you to slow down, savor, and connect with the heart of Amish craftsmanship.

Cultural Background

A Feast of Flavors and Artistry: What You’ll Find at Old Country Cheese

Planning Your Visit

Old Country Cheese is more than just a market—it’s a celebration of Amish heritage, craftsmanship, and community. From its mouthwatering jams and cheeses to its lovingly made crafts, every item is steeped in tradition and care. Visiting this charming specialty store is an opportunity to slow down, savor life’s simple pleasures, and take home a piece of Amish culture. Whether you’re a long-time lover of handmade goods or a curious first-time visitor, Old Country Cheese is sure to leave a lasting impression.

Keep exploring

All Amish stores in Wisconsin All Specialty Store More Specialty Store in Wisconsin

Contact Information

Address

S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI

Get Directions

Store Details

Type Specialty Store
Size small
Seasonal No

Products

jams jellies cheeses gifts crafts

Share

Help others discover this authentic Amish store

Facebook Twitter

Frequently Asked Questions

What payment methods does Old Country Cheese accept?

Most Amish stores including Old Country Cheese primarily accept cash. We recommend calling ahead at (608) 654-5411 to confirm current payment options. Some locations may also accept checks from local customers.

What are the hours of operation for Old Country Cheese?

Hours can vary by season and day of the week. Please call (608) 654-5411 to confirm current hours before visiting. Most Amish stores are closed on Sundays for religious observance.

What products can I find at Old Country Cheese?

Old Country Cheese offers jams, jellies, cheeses, gifts, crafts. A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.

Is Old Country Cheese open year-round?

Old Country Cheese is open year-round, but we recommend calling (608) 654-5411 to confirm hours before making a special trip.

Related Stores

🎁 Specialty Store

Amish House

N 5183 17th Drive, Wild Rose, WI

Amish House carries a broad choice of items including popcorn, syrups and Amish cheeses.

popcorn syrups cheeses
(920) 622-3338
Website
View Details