N5055 Hwy 14, Albany, WI
Cookies and candy made by Amish suppliers.
cookies candy
Phone listed Mapped
View listing
Old Country Cheese
Wisconsin / S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI
A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.
Listed hours are 8AM-5PM Monday through Saturday, closed Sunday; call (608) 654-5411 or check oldcountrycheese.com before visiting.
Listing Confidence
- Google Maps verified
- Jun 17, 2026
- Last updated
- Jun 4, 2025
- Phone
- (608) 654-5411
- Website
- oldcountrycheese.com
- Website status
- redirect
- Data checks
- generated id, phone formatting, website validation
- Business status
- operational
- Google rating
- 4.7 (359 reviews)
Details are shown only when present in the listing data. Call ahead to confirm hours and availability before making a special trip. View Google Maps listing. Report an update.
Verification sources:
Source 1
About Old Country Cheese
Old Country Cheese in Cashton, Wisconsin stocks Amish-made cheeses along with jams and jellies in flavors like apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple, gooseberry, and pumpkin butter, plus gifts and crafts. It is a broad stop for cheese and pantry preserves.
A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.
Contact Information
Address
S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI
Phone
(608) 654-5411Hours
Friday: 8AM-5PM; Monday: 8AM-5PM; Saturday: 8AM-5PM; Sunday: Closed; Thursday: 8AM-5PM; Tuesday: 8AM-5PM; Wednesday: 8AM-5PM
Closed Sundays
Website
oldcountrycheese.comStore Details
Type Specialty Store
Size small
Seasonal No
Products
jams jellies cheeses gifts crafts
Frequently Asked Questions
What does Old Country Cheese sell?
Amish-made cheeses, a wide range of jams and jellies, plus gifts and crafts.
What jam and jelly flavors are available?
Flavors include apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple, gooseberry, and pumpkin butter, among others.
When is it open?
Listed hours are 8AM-5PM Monday through Saturday, closed Sunday. Confirm at oldcountrycheese.com or by phone.
How do I pay?
Payment is cash.
Related Stores
5163 MCCARTHY ROAD LENA, Lena, WI
Amish and Mennonite bulk food products
bulk foods
Website listed Mapped
View listing
W5431 Lark Rd, Shawano, WI
Amish store with a variety of goods.
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.8 Google rating
View listing