A range of Amish made products such as jams and jellies (apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple jam, gooseberry, pumpkin butter), cheeses, gifts, crafts and much more.
Hours and availability should be confirmed before visiting. View Google Maps listing. Report an update. Own this business? How verification works.
Page-specific directory evidence
Old Country Cheese is recorded at S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI and classified as specialty store. Its directory record specifically names jams, jellies, cheeses, gifts, and crafts. 1 other specialty store listing is available elsewhere in Wisconsin.
Old Country Cheese is a specialty store in Cashton, Wisconsin, carrying Amish made cheeses, jams and jellies, gifts, and crafts.
The fruit spreads are the deepest part of the inventory. Stocked flavors include apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, and gooseberry, along with a dutch apple jam, plum butter, and pumpkin butter. The mix runs from common preserves to ones a regular grocery rarely carries, such as gooseberry and the butters. If you cook with preserves or want something beyond the standard grape and strawberry, the range here is worth a look. They suit toast and baking equally and make a low-cost item to take home.
The store sells Amish made cheese. Cheese pairs naturally with the preserves on the same shelves, and between the two you can put together most of a bread-and-spread table from one stop.
Alongside the food, Old Country Cheese stocks gifts and crafts. These are the non-grocery side of the store and are a reason to come in even if you are not buying pantry goods, whether you are picking up a present or browsing.
Payment is cash; no card reader is noted, so bring enough to cover what you intend to buy.
Specialty-store selection can be narrow, seasonal, or made to order. Confirm the exact product, size, material, price range, and pickup or delivery process when the purchase is time-sensitive. If maker or product origin matters, ask about the specific item rather than inferring it from the store name.
This page records the business name, location, category, and available contact or product details from the sources shown above. A Google Maps match or country-style business name does not by itself establish Amish ownership, who made every product, or what is in stock today. For those distinctions, ask the business about the specific item or relationship that matters to you. If you find an outdated address, closure, or product claim, use the listing correction form so the record can be reviewed.
Recorded product offerings. Call ahead to confirm seasonal stock.
Advertisement
Amish-made cheeses, a wide range of jams and jellies, plus gifts and crafts.
Flavors include apple, apricot, cherry, blackberry, peach, strawberry, plum butter, dutch apple, gooseberry, and pumpkin butter, among others.
Payment is cash.
Old Country Cheese is listed at S510 County Road D, Cashton, WI. Use the directions link and confirm the address with the business before a long trip.
Old Country Cheese is categorized in this directory as Specialty Store. Category labels describe the documented store format and do not by themselves establish ownership or where every item was made.
The current directory record mentions jams, jellies, cheeses, gifts, and crafts. Availability can change, so confirm the specific item and quantity before traveling.
Monday: 8AM-5PM; Tuesday: 8AM-5PM; Wednesday: 8AM-5PM; Thursday: 8AM-5PM; Friday: 8AM-5PM; Saturday: 8AM-5PM; Sunday: Closed. Hours from a saved public record checked Jun 17, 2026. Confirm the current schedule before visiting.
N4359 County Rd HH, Mauston, WI
Oak School Amish Shop is listed in Mauston, WI. Its current product range has not been independently confirmed. Check the available contact information before traveling for a specific item.
105 Parkway Ave N, Lanesboro, MN
Amish Experience offers Amish made products.
217 N Pioneer Park Rd, Westfield, WI
Amish House is a bulk foods store in Westfield, WI.
