A Mennonite-owned consignment store.
Nestled in the heart of Myerstown, Pennsylvania, Once Mine Now Yours Consignment offers visitors a delightful opportunity to explore the beauty of Mennonite craftsmanship, resourcefulness, and community spirit. While small in size, this specialty consignment store is big on character, serving as a hidden gem for locals and tourists alike who enjoy hunting for unique treasures and embracing the simplicity and authenticity of traditional Pennsylvania Dutch culture. Stepping through its doors feels less like entering a shop and more like a friendly visit to a neighborâs homeâone filled with curated goods that tell stories of lives lived and cherished memories shared.
Whether youâre a seasoned thrifter, a curious traveler, or simply someone looking for something extraordinary, Once Mine Now Yours Consignment invites you to slow down, reconnect with timeless values, and savor the joy of finding secondhand items imbued with history and purpose.
For those seeking a shopping experience thatâs more personal, meaningful, and connected to the rhythm of a simpler life, Once Mine Now Yours Consignment is a must-visit destination. Whether you leave with an armful of treasures or simply a renewed appreciation for Mennonite values, this charming store is sure to leave a lasting impression.
Most Amish stores including Once Mine Now Yours Consignment primarily accept cash. We recommend calling ahead at (717) 866-2882 to confirm current payment options. Some locations may also accept checks from local customers.
Hours can vary by season and day of the week. Please call (717) 866-2882 to confirm current hours before visiting. Most Amish stores are closed on Sundays for religious observance.
Once Mine Now Yours Consignment offers consignment goods. A Mennonite-owned consignment store.
Once Mine Now Yours Consignment is open year-round, but we recommend calling (717) 866-2882 to confirm hours before making a special trip.
12025 Susquehanna Trail, Glen Rock, PA
Sizeable market containing a broad choice of products provided by Amish and non-Amish vendors.
328 North Belmont Road, Gordonville, PA
Amish-owned road stand selling canned and home-baked goods.
State and Union Streets, Kennett Square, PA
Amish and non-Amish vendors, providing a wide array of foods, bulk foods, cheeses, groceries, fresh produce and much more.
