Amish Stores in Sarasota, FL

Browse Amish and plain-community store listings in Sarasota, Florida.

2 Stores Found

City market storefront row with produce baskets for local directory pages — Editorial regional image for trip planning, not a photo of a specific listed business.

Plan your visit to Sarasota

What you will find

Specialty Store

1 listing in this category lead the way, plus farm market.

Listing notes

restaurant

Directory listings for this city mention restaurant, bakery, coffee shop. Check individual store pages before you drive.

Trip timing

Call ahead

Hours can be limited and many Amish-owned businesses close on Sundays, so confirm details before you travel.

Browse by store type

Specialty Store (1) Farm Market (1)

What listings mention here

restaurant
bakery
coffee shop
vine ripe tomatoes
local grown potatoes
Amish jar goods

Specialty Store Verified

Carlisle Gifts Sarasota

Sarasota, FL

3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL

Offers a restaurant, bakery and coffee shop.

restaurant bakery coffee shop

Phone listed Website listed Mapped 4.7 Google rating

View listing

Farm Market

Yoder’s Fresh Market

Sarasota, FL

3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL

Yoders Fresh Market offers local produce daily including vine ripe tomatoes, local grown potatoes, Amish jar goods, jams and jellies, fresh baked goods and vast array of Amish.

vine ripe tomatoes local grown potatoes Amish jar goods jams and jellies +2 more

Phone listed Website repaired Mapped

View listing

Explore more of Florida

Sarasota is one of many communities in Florida. Browse the full state directory to plan a longer trip.

View all Florida listings

Travel tips for Sarasota

Start early on weekdays; many Amish and plain-community businesses close earlier than chain retailers and are closed on Sundays.
Use the product notes to prioritize stops for restaurant and bakery.
Bring cash and reusable bags. Many small stores prefer cash payments and appreciate shoppers who come prepared.

Frequently asked questions

What kinds of Amish stores are in Sarasota, FL?

Sarasota has 1 specialty store, 1 farm market. Common listing notes include restaurant, bakery, coffee shop.

When are the Amish stores in Sarasota open?

Stores in Sarasota are generally open Monday through Saturday with limited local hours. Amish-owned businesses are closed on Sundays.

How do I get to the Amish stores in Sarasota?

Sarasota, Florida is accessible by car. Use the directions link on each store listing for navigation and confirm the address before you travel.