Yoder’s Fresh Market

Florida / 3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL

Yoders Fresh Market offers local produce daily including vine ripe tomatoes, local grown potatoes, Amish jar goods, jams and jellies, fresh baked goods and vast array of Amish.

Produce availability changes daily, so call (941) 955-7771 or check the produce page at yodersrestaurant.com to confirm hours and current stock before you go.

Listing Confidence

Last updated
Jun 4, 2025
Phone
(941) 955-7771
Website
https://www.yodersrestaurant.com/deli/new-market/
Website status
verified_replacement
Data checks
generated id, phone formatting, website validation

Details are shown only when present in the listing data. Call ahead to confirm hours and availability before making a special trip. Report an update.

About Yoder’s Fresh Market

Yoder's Fresh Market is a farm market in Sarasota, Florida, selling local produce and Amish pantry goods.

Local produce

Fresh produce is restocked daily and makes up the bulk of what's on the shelves. Among the named items are vine ripe tomatoes and locally grown potatoes, alongside a broader range of local produce that turns over with what's available. If you're buying for the week rather than a single dish, this is the section to start in.

Amish jar goods and baked items

The store carries Amish jar goods, including jams and jellies, sold in sealed jars meant to keep on a shelf. Fresh baked goods are also stocked. The jar goods suit anyone wanting preserves or canned items they can store, while the baked goods are for shorter-term eating. Together these fill in around the fresh produce for a fuller grocery run.

Hours and payment

The market is open 9AM to 6PM. Payment is cash or check; no card option is noted, so plan to bring one of those if you're making a trip.

Contact Information

Address

3434 Bahia Vista Street, Sarasota, FL

Hours

9AM – 6PM

Closed Sundays

Store Details

Type Farm Market
Size medium
Seasonal No

Products

vine ripe tomatoes local grown potatoes Amish jar goods jams and jellies fresh baked goods local produce

Share

Help others discover this store listing

Frequently Asked Questions

What can I buy at Yoder's Fresh Market?

The market carries local produce daily, including vine-ripe tomatoes and locally grown potatoes, plus Amish jar goods, jams and jellies, and fresh baked goods.

Is the produce locally grown?

The listing notes the market offers local produce daily, including vine-ripe tomatoes and locally grown potatoes.

What payment methods are accepted?

Cash and check are listed as accepted payment methods.

How do I confirm hours?

Call (941) 955-7771 or check the produce market page at yodersrestaurant.com.

What payment methods does Yoder’s Fresh Market accept?

Most Amish stores including Yoder’s Fresh Market primarily accept cash. We recommend calling ahead at (941) 955-7771 to confirm current payment options. Some locations may also accept checks from local customers.

What are the hours of operation for Yoder’s Fresh Market?

Yoder’s Fresh Market is open: 9AM – 6PM. Like most Amish businesses, it is closed on Sundays for religious observance. Call (941) 955-7771 to confirm seasonal hours.

Related Stores

Farm Market Verified Closed

Farmish Market

Panama City, FL

3812 U.S. 98, Panama City, FL

Broad selection of Amish made products including jellies (elderberry, triple berry, gooseberry, blueberry, raspberry), roll butter, cheeses, meats and jerky, relishes, salsa, dressings and condiments, snacks and candy.

elderberry jelly triple berry jelly gooseberry jelly blueberry jelly +11 more
Phone listed Website listed Mapped 5 Google rating
View listing
General Market Verified

Bushel Stop Market LLC

Zephyrhills, FL

6520 Fort King Rd, Zephyrhills, FL

Offers fresh fruits and vegetables, honey, and other fresh foods.

fresh fruits vegetables honey fresh foods
Phone listed Website repaired Mapped 4.5 Google rating
View listing