Dutch Valley Market

The grocery side covers the standard pantry and household items you would shop for a week of meals, stocked under the Amish-grocery label. It suits a regular shopping trip rather than a single specialty purchase, and pairs with the meat counter so you can handle most of a grocery list in one stop.

The butcher shop is the other half of the store, offering a variety of meats cut and sold at the counter. This is the part of the market to come for if fresh and packaged meat is the main reason for the visit; the selection is broad enough to choose from rather than take what is set out.

The market is open 9AM to 5PM. Payment is cash or check, so plan to bring one of those rather than a card. Sugarcreek sits in the Holmes County area of eastern Ohio, and the store keeps regular daytime hours through the week.